Alternative Medicine?: A History by Roberta Bivins

By Roberta Bivins

Stroll into your neighborhood future health nutrients store or decide up the neighborhood paper, and youll see advertisements for meditation, acupuncture, natural supplementations, Tai Chi periods, homeopaths, religion healers, and chinese language herbalists. yet what precisely is substitute drugs? Is the surprising approval for replacement and multicultural medication particularly this kind of fresh improvement?
evaluating the clinical structures of China, India, and the west (both mainstream and alternative), this quantity levels throughout 4 centuries and plenty of continents, mapping the transmission of scientific services from one tradition to a different and laying naked the roots of modern-day differences among replacement, complementary, and orthodox medication. Historian Roberta Bivens makes use of a wealth of illuminating and unique old examples--from horse-racing English earls to determined missionaries in 17th-century Indonesia, and from hypnotism within the British Raj to homeopathy within the American Wild West--to underscore the very important aspect that the cross-cultural transmission of clinical wisdom and services, even substitute scientific wisdom and services, isn't really a uniquely modern phenomenon, yet has a protracted and interesting pedigree. via comparisons of alternative clinical options and importations throughout diverse cultures, the publication illuminates the dual techniques of clinical and ancient switch as visible throughout the eyes of the doctors and shoppers of the day. It lines for instance the responses in nineteenth-century India to 2 western replacement drugs (homeopathy and mesmerism) and one staple of mainstream western drugs (germ theory).
Given the good fortune of recent biomedical technology, why are substitute and standard remedies now so trendy? This interesting quantity sheds gentle in this pattern because it bargains a sweeping comparative account of different drugs over 400 years.

Show description

Read or Download Alternative Medicine?: A History PDF

Similar special topics books

Poucher's Perfumes, Cosmetics and Soaps

Poucher's Perfumes Cosmetics and Soaps has been in print on account that 1923 and is the vintage reference paintings within the box of cosmetics. Now in a completely up-to-date tenth variation, this new quantity offers a company easy wisdom within the technology of cosmetics (including toiletries) in addition to incorporating the most recent tendencies in clinical functions and laws that have happened because the ninth version.

Neural prostheses for restoration of sensory and motor function

The chance of interfacing the frightened process with digital units to stimulate or checklist from neural tissue indicates a number of probabilities within the box of neuroprosthetics. whereas the production of a "six million greenback guy" should be some distance into the longer term, neural prostheses are swiftly changing into doable theories for a extensive variety of sufferers with harm or ailment of the apprehensive procedure.

The heart of Leonardo

Leonardo's middle stories symbolize the head of his anatomical endeavours. They combine structural shape and dynamic functionality in a manner that referred to as upon his large adventure and information of hydrology, engineering, arithmetic and architectural layout. In his paintings at the center, his use of creative diagrams in addition to certain representational drawings is cleverly mixed with rigorously crafted verbal descriptions of complex physiological innovations.

Additional resources for Alternative Medicine?: A History

Sample text

Diet, levels of activity and rest, and ageing all aVected the state of the body, as did the weather, the changing seasons, and locality. Additionally, in Chinese and Indian medicine, and to an only slightly lesser degree, in western medicine, the healthful balance could be aVected by changing states either of body or of mind— excesses of emotion might either cause bodily illness or be caused by it. Consciousness in classical Chinese medical theory (as in the most materialistic models of western medicine today, though for rather diVerent reasons) was an organ of the body rather than a separate entity residing within it.

Of course, this process was not without its problems. Floyer often discarded or rewrote Chinese theories which were not consistent with European, anatomically informed, ideas of the body. 16 Though he clearly privileged anatomy and its evidence, Floyer did not accept his contemporaries’ claims for the supremacy of the anatomical approach to the body unquestioningly. He noted rather astringently that, Tho’ neither the Greeks nor the Chinese knew the true Fabrick of the Organs of the Pulse, nor their true action and uses, nor the circulation of humours, and the causes of it, yet the Greeks discovered the polses of all diseases and humours, and passions: And the Chinese their Art of Physic [based] on the pulse and its diVerences .

17 Floyer concluded, in essence, that a pulse by any name (or studied through any interpretive system) would beat as revealing a rhythm of sickness or health: I would plainly ask whether the art of the pulse be not the same whether we call the causes by the Chinese, Grecian, or Modern names? The diVerent names or hypothesis are fram’d and built after divers experiments have been try’d, and matters of fact clearly observ’d; and the hypothesis is always well adapted to the natural phenomena, and we may practice the Chinese as well as the old Grecian notions .

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.15 of 5 – based on 22 votes